Showing posts with label Dr. Twenge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dr. Twenge. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 20, 2017

Is Gen Z's intolerance of free speech driven by fear?



When my mother, a member of the Silent Generation, was dying, she told me that she was the best mother she knew, because she raised two such strong and independent children.  As a Baby Boomer, I was also raised in an era of hope, when we all believed we could have a coke and teach the world to sing in harmony.  We also believed in free speech.

That's why the recent controversies over free speech on college campuses caught me off guard.  

But when you think about it, the defining childhood event of Gen Z was 9/11.  And, it's easy to see why this led to helicopter parenting and a generation for whom safety is a priority. 

Based on her research, Dr. Twenge of San Diego State University notes that Gen Z's are more risk adverse than were previous generations; perhaps because they are more aware of their own mortality.  And because their world revolves around social media they have learned that words matter, and that every social interaction carries the risk of being hurt.  So, opposing viewpoints must be shut down because merely hearing them can cause harm. (Twenge, 2017)

Assuming that is true, it poses huge challenges in terms of persuasion.  How can you persuade someone to change their mind if they won't even listen to you?

So, what do you think?  Do you agree that Gen Z has been raised with fear?  Has it impacted their ability to entertain alternative points of view?  And if so, is there a way to get past it and connect so that we can begin to find common ground again?   Which of Robert Cialdini's principles might apply?


Twenge, J. (2017, September 1)  The Smartphone Generation Vs. Free Speech.  wsj.com.  Retrieved September 20, 2017, from  https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-smartphone-generation-vs-free-speech-1504274890?mg=prod/accounts-wsj